Delicious, and quick. But not simple.
Having being disappointed by the Cacio e Pepe we had in Italy (particularly not enough pepper (which IMHO should a predominant ingredient if it is in the name), too salty and/or lumpy), I thought I would try my hand at it.
The method for “Recipes from Italy” is the best recipe I have come across. https://www.recipesfromitaly.com/spaghetti-cacio-e-pepe-recipe/
It was sensational. My only comment is that as spaghetti normally cooks for 9 minutes in boiling water, and the recipe calls for taking out the pasta after 5 minutes, and cook the pasta for the remaining time in the pepper water on low, is that it takes a lot more than a further 4 minutes to cook the pasta al dente. It is a bit like cooking risotto you keep adding ladels of paster water, and the pasta seems to absorb the water. Probably took about 8 minutes in the pepper water to reach al dente.
5 ingredients. For 2:
- 175 g Pasta (usually dried spaghetti as that’s what the roman shepherds carried);
- 110 g Pecorino Romano DOP (plus some more for topping)
- 7 g Whole Black Peppercorns (plus more for topping)
- 1/4 tsp Salt, and
- 875 ml Water (N.B. this is about half the quantity of water, one would normally cook pasta in).
Steps:
- Smash the peppercorns. I used a pestle.
- Toast the smashed peppercorns in a large frypan.
- Par boil the pasta in lightly salted water. Respect the reduced quality of water as you want the starchy water.
- Add some pasta water to the peppercorns, and then the parboiled pasta.
- Finely grate the pecorino and add 1/2 cup of water to the cheese to make a paste.
- Gradually add more pasta water (like cooking a risotto) to the pasta. I used all the remaining pasta water to achieve al dente status.
- Turn off the heat and gradually stir in the cheese paste.
- Serve with more grated pecorino and black pepper.
- Do not add Butter, Oil or Cream!.
- Enjoy.









Leave a comment